>> schieffer: today on "face the nation" the legacy of senator ted kennedy. >> the world will long remember their son edward as the heir to a weighty legacy. a champion for those who had none. the soul of the democratic party and the lion of the united states senate. >> schieffer: his friends and family and millions who saw it on television said good bye to senator kennedy yesterday during a day of mourning that stretched into night. 47 years in the senate. hundreds of pieces of legislation. a life rife with tragedy. plus constant work on health

care, a cause of his life. what is senator kennedy's legacy? what made him such a good legislator? and what can be learned from the way he led his life? we'll talk with senators john mccain, republican of arizona; orrin hatch, republican of utah; dianne feinstein, democrat of california; representative barney frank, democrat of massachusetts, and georgetown university historian michael eric dyson. i'll have a final word on american hero and the family that held america's attention for half a century. remembering ted kennedy on "face the nation." captioning sponsored by cbs "face the nation" with cbs news chief washington correspondent bob schieffer. and now from cbs news in washington, bob schieffer. captioning sponsored by cbs

good morning again. joining us now first senator john mccain. senator, i understand that when vicki kennedy began calling people to speak at the wake on friday night that you were the first republican she called. i can understand why that was because you did have a very kind of special relationship with senator kennedy. you didn't always work together. a lot of the time you were on opposite sides but somehow you managed to keep this relationship going. how did you do that? >> i think it was probably because first of all we grew to respect each other. over time then have great affection for each other. you know, in this business& first you've got to establish respect. that respect sometimes was because of face-to-face discussions. sometimes for the record on issues that we had

disagreements on. but the thing about ted was that when the debate was over, then he would put his arm around you and you moved on to the next issue. he never held... not only didn't he hold a grudge. he would... that was done. now let's go on to the next battle. >> schieffer: i talked to bob dole on the day senator kennedy died. i asked him basically the same question i asked you. he said he had this ability to go out there on the floor and make these highly partisan speeches but somehow leave the impression that he wasn't talking about you personally. >> that's right. but the other thing that i think was so important about ted, the reason... one of the fundamental reasons for his success was once he gave his word, that was never broken. i'd love to tell you that that's a very common thing. but unfortunately it's not as common as we would like. he would even take votes that were counter to his his own

position in order to preserve the coalition that he had fashioned in order to reach a goal. when we were working on immigration reform, when he saw shof his some of his members straying he would give them a little straight talk. he would take votes that would look like they were counter to his position but were vital to preserving the fragility of any... whenever you're going to pass major legislation, you've got to have a coalition and you've got to preserve it. when you're on the floor. the enemies are always looking for amendments that will split that coalition. but the other thing is, you know, he was an affectionate man. he really enjoyed his friends. i wasn't nearly the close friend that chris dodd, for example, was and others. but i saw the genuine affection that he held for his staff, for his friends. we all know how devoted he was to his family. anybody who saw ted kennedy jr.'s statement yesterday had to be genuinely moved by the

devotion that this father had to his children and his family. when russ feingold and i got the profile in courage award i saw him with the whole family, the whole... all the kids, grand kids. he truly was the patriarch. he kept that family together. >> schieffer: i want to ask you since you are here, i asked you to come and talk about senator kennedy. but this morning on fox former vice president cheney said that the president's... the administration's decision to appoint special council to look into the torture allegations was in his words a terrible decision. he said-- and these were his words-- it offended the hell out of me. i know you were against torture. and tried to do something about that. but do you agree with the vice president, the former vice president, that somebody should not have been appointed to look into this? >> i believe that the

president was right when he said we ought to go forward and not back. i worry about the more al and effectiveness of the c.i.a.. i worry about this thing getting out of control and us harming our ability to carry on the struggle that we're in with radical islamic extremism. look, i was radically opposed to it. i think it harmed us. i think torturing harmed us. i have a number of anecdotes that could substantiate that. i think it harmed our image in the world but for us now to go back i think would be a serious mistake. >> schieffer: the president had said that he wanted to go forward but this apparently is a decision made by the attorney general. and the president i guess says he's going to go along with it. >> well, the attorney general has a unique position in the cabinet obviously. he can't be told what to do by the president of the united

states but i think it's a mistake. i think in the future we'll find its a mistake. at the same time we can assure the american people that it will never happen again. and people in the world that has harmed our image so badly. >> schieffer: do you agree with the vice president when he says this has kept the country safe all this time since this attack and it is because these interrogations worked and we found out information that helped us keep the country safe. >> i think the interrogations were in violation of the geneva convention against torture that we ratified under president reagan. i think that these interrogations once publicized helped al qaeda recruit. i got that from an al qaeda operative in a prison camp in iraq who told me that. i think that the ability of us to work with our allies was harmed. and so... and i believe that

information according to the f.b.i. and others could have been gained through other methods. >> schieffer: when you say an al qaeda operative told you it helped them. >> senator lindsey graham and i were in the camp where there's the 20,000-prisoner camp. we met with a former high- ranking member of al qaeda. i said how did you succeed so well in iraq after the initial invasions. he said two things. the chaos that existed after the initial invasion there was no order of any kind. two, he said abu ghraib pictures allowed me and helped me to recruit thousands of young men to our cause. now that's al qaeda. and the second thing about it is if you inflict enough pain on anyone, they'll tell you anything to make the pain stop. so you not only get perhaps right information but you also get a lot of wrong information. but the damage that it did to america's image in the world is something we're still on the way to repairing. this is an ideological strug...

struggle as well as a physical one. >> schieffer: senator mccain, thank you so much for coming by to share those stories about senator kennedy and also about the comments on the news of the day. >> thank you for having me on, bob. >> schieffer: okay. i want to go now to boston where senator dianne feinstein, who served with senator kennedy on the judiciary committee, is standing by. also with us this morning from portland maine congressman barney frank who is from senator kennedy's home state, of course, massachusetts. senator feinstein, let me just start where senator mccain left off. this whole controversy where you have the vice president now saying that he thought it was a terrible decision driven by politics for the attorney general to appoint a special council to look into these charges of torture. we'll talk about senator kennedy in just a minute but since you are on judiciary i wanted to get your thoughts on

that. >> really my thoughts as chairman of the intelligence committee i think is what is probably most relevant. i have read the 2004 inspector- general report. it is a stunning report. i've read it in its unredacted version. it's true. i was horrified. so i understand the attorney general's reaction. however, i think the timing of this is not very good. the intelligence committee has underway now a total look at the interrogation and detention techniques used for all of the high-value detainees. we're well along in that study. i'm trying to push it along even more quickly at this time. we are not going to be detered from completing this study. and candidly, i wish that the attorney general had waited. every day something kind of dribbles out into the public

arena. very often it has mistakes. very often it's half a story. i think we need to get the whole story together and tell it in an appropriate way. a lot of things are being said. well, you know, torturing people is something that we did. but on the other hand it produced all kinds ofen credible information. it did produce some information but there is a great discrepancy and i think a good deal of error out there in what people are saying it did produce. we need to straighten that out. the only thing that is going to straighten it out is a very comprehensive look at it. this is a bipartisan effort of the senate intelligence committee. it should be able... we should be able to finish it hopefully not too long from now. >> schieffer: let's... let me... thank you very much. let me ask you now about senator ken deechlt you were at the funeral yesterday.

you served on the judiciary committee a long time with senator kennedy. you were not there during the bork hearings when senator kennedy said some very tough things. i mean, the thing we always remember is the quote he gave where he said robert bork's america is a land in which women would be forced into back alley abortions, blacks would sit at segregated lunch counters, rogue police could break down citizens' doors in midnight rage. children could not be taught about evolution. many people said that after senator kennedy said that, that the whole confirmation process about supreme court candidates changed after that. do you think that was a good part or a bad part of his legacy? >> well i'm not going to put it that way because i wasn't there. i do think that the process has changed. i do think it's become much more partisan. there are many of us on that committee that are trying very

hard to end that kind of partisanship. i was very surprised, for example, when justice sotomayor was not confirmed by more republicans on the committee than voted for her. because i thought she was just a sure thing and a great american story. and very well qualified. this, in fact, was an historic nomination because she would have been the first latina ever to sit on the united states supreme court. but what was so amazing about senator kennedy was this. he truly had a civil rights anti-discrimination human rights agenda that was deep in his heart. he led the committee, i believe, in social issues. he had worked on them for years. he cared deeply.

he was a robust sub committee chair. he controlled the sub committees. he put together legislation. he lobbied it through. when he needed to groms, he compromised but he was a very dominant figure on that committee. and when he spoke, everybody listened. there was no question to that. he's a leader. >> schieffer: a leader. >> and a great leader. >> schieffer: let me bring in barney frank because that brings me to another part of it. they were just talk to go senator mccain talking about how he was able to maintain these relationshipes. but as a democrat, congressman frank, from his home state, what do you think it was that made him so successful? what senator mccain has said over the years are most effective member of the senate? >> three things, bob, one of which we talked about. we start with two others. first of all he knew his stuff. ted kennedy hired consistency the smartest and best minds that he could get. he went into any negotiation

knowing the substance better than almost anybody. as senator feinstein knows particularly if you're a united states senator you're on several committees and sub committees. your ability to stay on top of things, it can be hard. members of the house, the same thing. with too much staff, ted had a first rate staff. he mastered that material and did his work. when ted kennedy sat down, he knew things. knowing your material is important. secondly he was a very good politician. we talk about politics. he knew the way to negotiate was the best thing you could do was maybe something will be important to the other guy that's not so important to you and it will be important to you and not so important to her. that's the way you put it together. this is the final thing we talked b it relates to what senator feinstein said about the nomination. we're getting more polarized in america today. i wish more people were watching programs like this, you know, a lot of us do, because what you have now is there's not the common body of information out there for the

most active people politically. the most conservative people listen to talk radio. people on the left tend to be on the internet. they don't have enough knowledge of what other people think. they tend to frankly listen to media. the most active people that reinforce their own views. the problem there is that if you then want to make a compromise, which is essential for almost anything particularly since we've had a de facto amendment to the u.s. constitution 60 votes instead of 51 is needed for the senate. very unusual in our history, its hard to do that. because the people who make the compromises will be accused by their own ideological partisans of giving in for no good reason. if we say to them, look we didn't have the votes to do this, they say but everybody i talk to on the internet, everybody who calls in this talk show they agree with me. what helped ted kennedy was this. no one could attack him from the left. you might disagree him on the specific issue. but as senator feinstein said look at his agenda. no one in american history has done more to advance the cause

of fairness in our country, economically, socially and every other way. ted kennedy had the ability and the knowledge to get into a political situation and make the compromises. he knew that there might be some people who might be unhappy with this one or that one. but no one would credibley say, oh, ted kennedy sold us out for no good reason. that's an essential thing if you're going to have the ability to make deals. >> schieffer: when we come back we'll take a little break here, we're going to bring in orrin hatch and michael eric dyson. we'll also... they also knew senator kennedy very well. >> i have serious reservations about our policy in vietnam. and the pursuit of that policy in vietnam. i think that that is the overriding consideration and the question that is before our nation. it pervades every other aspect of not only the life in this country but our domestic programs.

introducing the all new chevy equinox. with an epa estimated 32 miles per gallon. and up to 600 miles between fill ups. it's the most fuel efficient crossover on the highway. better than honda cr-v, toyota rav4 and even the ford escape hybrid. the all new chevy equinox.

>> with us here in the studio senator orrin hatch republican of utah who worked on many pieces of legislation with senator kennedy and michael eric dyson georgetown university the historian sociologist who has written extensively about among other things barack obama. senator hatch, let me just talk to you first. you told some wonderful stories. somebody told me this story about you. they said that talking about how senator kennedy had a way of making people feel special. they said many of your colleagues used to encourage you and congratulate you on your hobby of song writing. but they said senator kennedy would come to your office and listen to those songs and he actually knew the words to some of them. he did have a way, did he not, of making people feel kind of special at the moment? >> he did. he was a master politician and a very good friend. we fought each other most of the time, knock-down drag-out battles.

afterwards we'll throw our arms around each other and say how did i do? i'd laugh. i'd yell at him. but he was a masterful politician. >> schieffer: how is it that he was able to find that sort of sweet spot in the legislation as somebody said to me this week that the other person, the person on the other side of the issue could be for? >> even though he was very liberal. he would listen to, for instance, myself and realize there were things he couldn't do. take the chip program. when we finally did it, it was a moderate to conservative bill. he came all the way across the center into even the conservative side. he was add first when i put that bill into the balanced budget act of that year. the first balanced budget in over 40 years. he came down and started yelling at me. all of a sudden they started to laugh because i started to laugh at him. he realized how important it was. and it turned out to be one of the most important. we did dozens and dozens of landmark pieces of legislation.

a lot of it was because he was able to acknowledge that he couldn't get everything he wanted through but if he worked with us, he could get some things that were good and, of course, i had to do the same. >> schieffer: michael eric dyson, you wrote a lot about barack obama. you probably knew obama better than he knew ted kennedy. let me ask you this question. do you think barack obama would have been elected had not ted kennedy endorsed him? >> no, i don't think so. >> schieffer: really? >> obviously he had a lot of momentum behind him. i don't want to say he couldn't have been elected without ted kennedy but ted kennedy's endorsement made it a lot easier. of course barack obama had the winds of hope and possibility behind him but ted kennedy was an awful powerful gust of wind that gave him a necessary lift. this was a man of american royalty. bestowing upon mr. obama, if you will, the mantle of that& kind of liberal leadership as senator hatch has talked about and the courage to stick to your convictions not to be

uncompromising and unyielding but to understand the difference between compromise and protective strategy and compromising the fundamental principle. i think his endorsement made america look seriously at this young man and those who were sitting on the fence to become much more committed to him and those who were already encouraged by mr. obama's rise to go even further. >> schieffer: there's no question that senator obama appreciated that. and understood what it meant. did he ever say to you or did those around him ever say to you why they thought in the end that senator kennedy decided to endorse obama? this was a major thing. he was taking on a big part of the democratic party when he did. >> it was. with caroline kennedy's endorsement the day before to the "new york times" in the op-ed and senator kennedy the next day but i think this senator kennedy identified in barack obama the same hopefulness he had seen glowing in the face of his brother john and radiating of the heart from his brother robert. i think there was a kind of trilogy, if you will. kennedy himself didn't make it

to the presidency. his though he ran. but i think he saw in barack obama the passing of the baton. he saw something new, some ken it i can spirit, some amazing charisma that was able to catalize the ambition of millions of people. when he spotted it he knew the real thing. he knew barack obama was the real deal. so throwing his weight behind obama was a way of continuing his... ted kennedy's legacy and also latching on to the legacy of an extraordinary phenom. >> schieffer: a very short time left. how will the senate be different now that he is gone, senator? >> there was no other democrat who could carry the base of the democratic party and get them to do what really has to be done in a compromise situation. you see this in health care. the base doesn't want to give in on what's called the government plan. that's a big part of it plus they want the mandates on employers or employees plus they want to move more people into medicaid so they can gradually get on to a single pay-or system. kennedy would know a number of those things can't be done in

a bipartisan way. >> schieffer: i want to thank both of you. we'll be back with the final word in just a minute. to do business on a smarter planet... ...you need to open your business to the world. invite customers into the design process. work with people far outside the firewall. collaborate with business partners... get insights from suppliers anywhere... unlock knowledge from our supply chain. smarter technology means the choice... ...between being open... ...and being secure isn't a choice anymore. i can have both. helping to secure an open world. that's what i'm working on. i'm an ibmer. let's build a smarter planet. if your kids can go onward and upward, no matter what. if you get side-lined from work. insuring your family's ifs can be confusing. so metlife removed the guesswork. combining two essential insurances... term life and disability... in one affordable package.

creating a personal safety net that's bursting with guarantees. for the if in life, find out how to start protecting your family today. visit the term life and disability tool at metlife.com. when morning comes in the middle of the night, [ rooster crow ] it affects your entire day. to get a good night's sleep, try 2-layer ambien cr. the first layer dissolves quickly... to help you fall asleep. and unlike other sleep aids, a second dissolves slowly to help you stay asleep. when taking ambien cr, don't drive or operate machinery. sleepwalking, and eating or driving... while not fully awake with memory loss for the event... as well as abnormal behaviors... such as being more outgoing or aggressive than normal, confusion, agitation and hallucinations may occur. don't take it with alcohol... as it may increase these behaviors. allergic reactions such as shortness of breath, swelling of your tongue or throat may occur... and in rare cases may be fatal. side effects may include next-day drowsiness, dizziness, and headache. in patients with depression, worsening of depression,

including risk of suicide may occur. if you experience any of these behaviors or reactions... contact your doctor immediately. wake up ready for your day-- ask your healthcare provider for 2-layer ambien cr. finally as i watched ted kennedy's funeral yesterday, i thought of a book i read last week called "the art of racing in the rain" in which the protagonist observes that no race has ever been won on the first turn but many have ended there. ted kennedy crashed and crashed again during the early turns of his life but somehow he kept on going through the sorrows and tragedies over which he had no control and the self-destructiveness over which he did. in the final laps he won. his children loved him. his contemporaries even those who often opposed hip admired him. those whose causes he championed thanked him. to what else can a man aspire? his personal friend and sometime political foe the long-time republican leader

bob dole told me the day kennedy died that what impressed him was the kennedy boys could have gone through life and never worked a day. but all of them did. the thousands of laws that he authored changed the lives of millions who were less fortunate, a legacy few can match. in a sense he was the classic american hero, the imperfect man who was sorely tested and yet in that testing found a way to overcome personal flaws and go on to accomplish great things. you didn't have to agree with his politics to appreciate what he achieved. ted kennedy made a difference. back in a minute. you like your health coverage, but worry what happens...

if you get sick, or change jobs. eight ways reform matters to you. a cap on deductibles and out-of-pocket costs. no annual or lifetime limits on coverage. preventive care. covered. pre-existing conditions. covered. no higher rates due to gender. extended coverage for young adults. no more coverage denied if you get sick. and guaranteed renewal, even if you do. learn more today. >> schieffer: and we'll see you next sun sum right here on "face the nation." captioning sponsored by cbs